Entitled vs Smart SEO: an SEO suite and a product data app, compared from their own pages
Last reviewed
Short answer
Smart SEO AI & Image Optimizer, by Sherpas Design, is a broad Shopify SEO suite: AI meta and alt tags, image and speed work, JSON-LD, broken links, IndexNow and an LLM catalog, free to start and $14.99 a month for Pro. Entitled is a narrow $4.99 a month app that scores product data against the published AI shopping feed rules and writes approved fixes to native Shopify fields. Pick Smart SEO for breadth, Entitled for product data.
At a glance
Ratings, review counts, prices and features below were observed on each app's Shopify App Store listing on 22 November 2026 and change over time. Everything stated about Smart SEO is drawn from its own listing and its developer's product page, and the sources are at the foot of this page. We make Entitled, so read our column with the same scepticism you would read anyone's.
| Entitled | Smart SEO AI & Image Optimizer | |
|---|---|---|
| Developer | Banana for Scale AS | Sherpas Design, Sofia, Bulgaria |
| App Store rating | 5.0 stars, 3 reviews | 5.0 stars, 959 reviews, Built for Shopify |
| On the App Store since | 2026 | 6 August 2015 |
| Free plan | AI-Readiness Score for the whole store, the {{year}} variable, 10 AI generations, 1 free variable | Meta and alt tag optimization, sitemap, noindex tags, 20 AI generations, 50 image optimizations, broken link check and audit on 20 to 100 pages |
| Paid plans | Pro $4.99/month | Pro $14.99, Business $24.99, Premium $49.99 a month; yearly options save 17% |
| Free trial | Free plan has no time limit | 7 days on paid plans |
| Image compression and page speed | No | Yes |
| JSON-LD structured data | No theme schema | Yes, from Pro |
| IndexNow | Every approved change submitted automatically, on every plan | From Pro |
| llms.txt and agents.md | No | LLMs.txt and Agents.md catalogues from Pro |
| Scoring products against AI shopping feed specs | Yes, every product, against the published OpenAI and Google limits | Not described on its listing |
| Tracking AI mentions | Weekly samples of ChatGPT, Perplexity and Claude answers | Not described on its listing; its MCP server and Sidekick integration let AI agents read your Search Console data, from Pro |
| Languages | English | 20 languages |
What each app is actually for
Smart SEO's listing calls it SEO, AEO and GEO in one app, and the feature list backs that up. It writes meta tags, alt text and product descriptions with AI, compresses and renames images, improves page speed, adds JSON-LD, finds and fixes broken links, reports backlinks, controls noindex tags and sitemaps, automates IndexNow, and publishes an LLM catalog meant to help AI assistants discover products. Its MCP server lets AI agents read your Search Console data. It is a full technical SEO suite with an AI layer, and a very well reviewed one.
Entitled does one job. It reads every product in the catalog, grades the title, description and attributes against the rules AI shopping surfaces publish, such as OpenAI's 150-character title limit, explains each failure, and drafts a rewrite you approve before anything is written. It submits each change through IndexNow and samples ChatGPT, Perplexity and Claude weekly, so you can see whether mentions move. It does not compress images, add schema or check links.
So this is not really a head-to-head. It is a question of which problem you have. If a crawl report shows slow pages, missing structured data and broken links, that is Smart SEO territory. If your products are called things like The Cosy Throw and an assistant cannot tell that it is a machine-washable merino blanket, that is the problem Entitled exists for.
AI-written meta tags versus graded product data
Both apps use AI to write copy, and the difference is in what the copy is checked against. Smart SEO's listing says its AI writes meta tags, alt tags and descriptions, with 20 generations on the free plan and up to 1,200 on Premium, and Premium lets you bring your own AI key for unlimited generations. That is a fast way to fill empty fields across a large catalog.
Entitled starts from a score instead of a generator. Each product is graded against published limits and the reasons are shown, so you can see that a title is failing because it has no material or size, not just that it is short. The rewrite is then drafted to fix the named failure, and nothing is written until you approve it. Every change goes to the native Shopify SEO fields, with a snapshot taken first so any change can be undone, and those fields stay put if you uninstall.
Which approach suits you depends on catalog size and how much you trust bulk output. A store with 3,000 products and blank alt text gets more from bulk generation. A store with 80 products that are present but vague gets more from knowing exactly which ones fail and why. Our page on product titles for AI shows what the graded version looks like in practice.

Theme access and uninstalling
Smart SEO's listing, under data access, says the app needs to edit Online Store pages, script tags and the theme, as well as products, collections, files, translations and navigation. That is normal for a suite that adds structured data and speed work, which has to live somewhere on the storefront. We could not find Smart SEO's uninstall behaviour documented on its listing or on its developer's product page as of 22 November 2026, so we make no claim either way. Ask its support before you rely on it, and see how the main SEO apps document uninstalling.
Entitled adds no theme code. Approved titles and descriptions are written to the same native Shopify SEO fields you would edit by hand. Uninstall it and your storefront does not change.
Pricing, compared honestly
Smart SEO's free plan is real and many small stores will not outgrow it. Pro at $14.99 a month, or $149.90 a year, adds Search Console integration through MCP and Sidekick, the llms.txt and agents.md catalogues, JSON-LD, IndexNow, page speed and bulk editing. Business at $24.99 adds AI bulk generation for meta and alt tags, image filename optimization, backlinks and multi-language support. Premium at $49.99 adds unlimited audits, broken link automation and dedicated support.
Entitled has one paid plan at $4.99 a month. The readiness score, with the explanation of every failing rule, is free with no time limit, so the cheapest honest move is to measure your catalog before paying either of us. If the score says your product data is fine, you do not need Entitled.
Where Smart SEO is genuinely stronger
Track record, first. Smart SEO has been on the App Store since August 2015, carries the Built for Shopify badge, and holds 5.0 stars across 959 reviews, and recent reviews on its listing, read on 22 November 2026, keep returning to hands-on support for schema and duplicate markup problems. Entitled launched in 2026 with three reviews. That gap is real and you should weigh it.
Breadth, second. Image compression, JSON-LD, broken links, backlinks, sitemaps, multi-language SEO in 20 interface languages, and an MCP server that lets assistants read your Search Console data are all things Entitled does not do. If you want one app for the technical layer of Shopify SEO plus a first step into AI search, Smart SEO covers more ground than we do, and it is in our comparison of the best Shopify SEO apps for that reason.
Can you run both?
Yes, and for many stores it is the sensible setup: Smart SEO for images, speed, schema and links, Entitled for product titles, descriptions and attributes. The one rule is to give meta title and description authority to a single app. If two apps write the same fields, the last writer wins and you cannot tell which change did what. Turn off Smart SEO's meta automation for the products Entitled manages, or the other way round. Both apps submit to IndexNow, which is harmless: a repeated ping for the same URL is not a problem.
Choose Smart SEO if, choose Entitled if
Choose Smart SEO if you need a broad technical SEO suite, image and speed work, structured data and broken link fixing in one place, support in many languages, and a long review history, and you are comfortable with an app that edits your theme.
Choose Entitled if what you need is product data that AI shopping surfaces can actually read, graded against published rules, written into your own Shopify fields, approved by you one change at a time, for $4.99 a month. Not sure which problem you have? Run the free AI visibility check first. Neither app can guarantee that an assistant will recommend you, and you should distrust any app that says otherwise.
Frequently asked questions
Is Entitled a Smart SEO alternative?
Only for part of what Smart SEO does. Entitled covers product titles, descriptions and meta fields, graded against AI shopping feed rules. It does not do Smart SEO's image optimization, page speed, JSON-LD, broken links or backlinks, so stores that rely on those should keep a technical SEO suite.
How much does Smart SEO cost?
As observed on 22 November 2026, Smart SEO AI & Image Optimizer has a free plan, Pro at $14.99 a month, Business at $24.99 and Premium at $49.99, with yearly billing saving 17% and a 7-day trial on paid plans. Entitled is $4.99 a month with a free readiness score.
Does Smart SEO help with AI search?
Its listing says so: it describes AEO and GEO tools including an LLM catalog, llms.txt and agents.md catalogues, and an MCP server for Search Console insights. Its listing does not describe grading products against the published AI shopping feed specifications, which is the core of what Entitled does.
Who makes Smart SEO?
Sherpas Design, a developer based in Sofia, Bulgaria, according to its App Store listing. The app launched on the Shopify App Store on 6 August 2015.
Sources
Keep reading
Score your own catalog
Entitled grades every product against the rules on this page, explains each failure, and fixes them with AI you approve. The score is free forever.
